Academy
1395
A logical
follow-up to Academy's M10 GMC series, this is a kit of the 90mm
M36. It shares a lot of parts with the older kits, with additional
sprues providing the new turret, hull front plates, and rear engine
deck details.
The
total number of plastic parts is 625 (with many of those left over
for your spares box), plus nylon twine for the tow cable, flexible
"rubber band" tracks, and a decal sheet. As the kit is
based on the earlier M10 kits, you can build either the gasoline
powered M36 (built on the M10A1 hull with the larger engine deck
grill) or the M36B2 with diesel engine (based on the M10 hull with
the smaller grill) using the appropriate engine deck parts in the
box.
While
the instruction booklet points out different choices in parts during
the assembly, you need to first consult the paint and decal page
to determine which of the versions you are going to build. For example,
there are two different glacis plates, allowing you to build either
a WWII version, which did not have the .30 cal bow MG, or the post-war
version which did incorporate the gun. Some modelers may be misled
by the bow gun in the box art, which one could easily assume is
a WWII illustration. So with several building options, you need
to be careful with your choice of parts in this kit.
The
third M36 variant, the M36B1, used this turret on a standard M4A3
hull (as presented in Italeri's old kit). This came out of an urgent
need for more tank destroyers on the front lines in 1944. Only 187
were built by the end of that year, but the M36B1 was the most heavily
armored U.S. tank destroyer during the war, and the only one with
a bow machine gun. The turret from this kit could be used on a stock
M4A3 hull, and the left over Academy hull converted into a M35 prime
mover, but that is another story.
This
is the nicest plastic suspension available in a kit. You're provided
with several options. Drive sprockets are the simple plate sprockets,
or the revised fancy sprockets. Road wheels are either the stamped
solid spoke or open spoked versions, both with excellent details.
However, photos suggest that the solid spoke wheels were used most,
if not all, of the time. These wheels come with rear inserts for
detail on both sides. This is also the case with the idlers. Again,
check your references.
The
suspension bogies, which originated with Academy's M12 kit, are
the heavy duty VVSS with straight return roller arm and spacer,
and casting numbers are included. You have a choice of the earliest,
round track skid or the more familiar skid, that leans toward the
front of the vehicle. For a late vehicle like the M36, the later
skid seems the only option. The skids are molded separately thus
making clean up and filling of the joint on the top of the bogie
quite easy, and some thinning will improve the appearance. Details
can be enhanced by adding the bolts to the skids, and drilling four
mounting holes on the front of each bogie. These bogies were interchangeable
between sides of the vehicles, and the return roller arm could be
mounted on either side of the bogie.
The
supplied plain rubber block tracks are nicely molded, but you could
also use a set of T45 steel chevron tracks from Tamiya's M4A3, especially
if you are building your kit for a winter time period.
There
are two choices for the one-piece transmission cover, either sharp
nosed or more rounded.
The
lower hull has the essential interior components including gearbox,
crew seats, steering levers, foot pedals, and instrument panel.
The fighting compartment has the lower floor included, together
with a fire wall and the sponson mounted ammunition. This isn't
correct, as it shows the layout used in the M10. Nevertheless, it
would be hard to notice and at least there's something back there
to look at.
The
engine compartment gets side walls and fuel tanks, but no engine.
That's a pity because the engine doors are separate parts. As said,
you get parts for M36 and M36B2. The instructions have you build
an M36 with the M4A3 pattern rear plate and engine doors. The M36B2
uses the same the upper hull as in the M10 kits with all the parts
provided. (NOTE: If you build the M36, you can use the spare M36B2
parts to update Italeri's M4 Marines. This is supposed to be an
M4A2 but it does not provide the correct rear plate details and
exhaust arrangement. These are covered with wading trunk so they
are not necessarily visible, but if you're not using the trunks,
you'll need to add those details.)
The
hatches in the M36 kit are quite nice, with separate periscopes
and handles. These are mounted onto a one piece upper hull, together
with the front plate. Overall, the other details are good, but the
headlight guards could use some thinning down, the tools need attachment
straps, and the rear exhaust deflector is a bit thick.
The
turret is quite busy and has nice details included. Again, small
improvements can be made, such as wiring. The gun assembly is much
better than the one in Italeri's M36B1, and the turret basket has
the correct layout. There is no ammo to fill the ready round bins
in the turret bustle.
Academy
provides three barrels: a barrel with thread protector without muzzle
brake; the late war double baffle muzzle brake; or the post-war
single baffle muzzle brake with bore evacuator. Sadly, the barrel
with threaded end is not provided.
For
the rear MG mounting, you can choose between .30 and .50 cal. In
the field, M36s often had the .50 cal moved from the awkward rear
bustle position to the left front of the turret opening, or they
supplemented firepower with .30 cal MGs. The bits on the turret
rear for stowing the .50 cal are good and are easier to attach than
photoetch parts.
Turret
roof armor is an option, but Academy gives the folding flaps as
one big part, instead of the three actual segments. Create three
sections by cutting between hinges two and three, and four and five.
Usually, the middle section was left shut. You will also need to
score the divides between the small flaps that open for the gunner
on the front and right of the armor (Squadron's U.S. Tank Destroyers
in Action is a good reference for this).
Academy
provides a variety of casting markings, letters, numbers, bolts,
tie-downs, and other bits to further detail your vehicle.
You
get four options for markings, all for vehicles painted olive drab:
- U.S.
vehicle in France 1944 from the 705th Tank Destroyer battalion,
registration number and stars
- U.S.
vehicle in Germany 1945, "Pork Chop," registration number
and white stars
- U.S.
vehicle in Korea, no name and simple markings consisting of registration
number and white stars
- French
vehicle in Indochina 1953, "Puma," with the elaborate
marking on the turret
Overall,
this is a good kit. There are a lot of parts, resulting in a nicely
filled Sherman bits box, and the quality of detail and molding is
good. Of course, there's room for improvement, but out of the box
you get a nice model of the M36.
If
you want to use detail sets, there are several options out there,
including:
- Formations
has a two-barrel set (F038) that gives you a smooth taper barrel,
and a barrel with threaded end and thread protector
- Eduard
has two sets with details for the interior (35664) and the exterior
(35671)
- Royal
Models has three sets, plus a 'generic' M10 engine set (362)
- Set
355 has four frets of photo etch plus some resin bits
- Set
382 has just the plates for the turret roof armor
- Set
392 includes roof armor and two .30 cal MGs. This set is geared
toward the French RBCEO version in Indochina, as the MGs have
armored shields included and these aren't commonly seen on
WW2 vehicles
- Verlinden
Productions has a set which includes an engine, several resin
bits, and photoetch (2111).
-Martin
Dogger-
|